Deposit disputes are decided on paper, and the paper that decides them is the inventory. The three government-approved schemes in England and Wales all run the same way: the deposit is the tenant's money, the landlord who wants to keep any of it has to prove the loss, and the adjudicator never visits the property. If the check-in report does not show the carpet was clean on the day the tenant moved in, the claim for cleaning it on the day they moved out fails, however true it is. This guide explains what an inventory needs to contain, how check-in and check-out reports fit together, and what adjudicators actually look for.

Why the burden sits with the landlord

Under the tenancy deposit provisions of the Housing Act 2004, every deposit taken on an assured tenancy in England must be protected in an authorised scheme within 30 days and the prescribed information served on the tenant. The Renters' Rights Act 2025 carried those requirements into the periodic tenancy regime that applies to new assured tenancies from 1 May 2026, with the same penalties: a court can order the landlord to pay the tenant between one and three times the deposit, and a court cannot make a possession order on any ground other than the anti-social behaviour Grounds 7A and 14 until the deposit is protected and the prescribed information served, or the deposit has been returned (in full or with agreed deductions), or a deposit claim under section 214 has been decided, withdrawn or settled. An unprotected deposit never reaches an adjudicator at all: any dispute goes to court instead, where the tenant can also claim one to three times the deposit whatever the inventory shows.

Within the scheme, the adjudicator's starting point is that the money belongs to the tenant. A landlord claiming a deduction must show, on the balance of probabilities, that the tenant breached the tenancy, that the landlord suffered a loss as a result, and what that loss was worth. Each limb needs evidence, and the first two depend almost entirely on the comparison between the property at the start and the property at the end.

What an inventory is, and what it is not

An inventory and schedule of condition is a room-by-room list of everything in the property, with a note of its condition and cleanliness at the date of the record. "Everything" means the fabric of the room (walls, ceiling, floor, windows, doors, sockets, light fittings) as well as the contents, so an unfurnished let still needs a full inventory. A list of furniture with no condition notes is not a schedule of condition and will not prove anything about the state of the walls.

Three qualities make an inventory useful as evidence:

  • Specific descriptions. "Good condition" tells an adjudicator nothing. "Cream emulsion, two small scuffs at skirting height by the door, otherwise clean and unmarked" tells them exactly what the tenant inherited.
  • A consistent grading key for condition and for cleanliness, applied room by room, so that "professionally clean" at check-in can be compared with "domestically clean" at check-out without argument about words.
  • Dated photographs embedded in, or cross-referenced to, the written entries. Photographs on their own, with no description, are routinely discounted because the adjudicator cannot tell what they are meant to show or when they were taken.

The check-in report

The check-in is the inventory as agreed at the start of the tenancy. It should be completed on, or within a day or two of, the day the keys are handed over, ideally with the tenant present, and it should record the meter readings, the keys and fobs supplied, the smoke and carbon monoxide alarm tests, and the condition of the garden and any outbuildings. Both parties sign and date it.

If the tenant is not present, send the report to them promptly and give a written window, seven days is the usual figure, in which to raise any disagreement. Record that you did so. A report the tenant received, had the chance to challenge and did not challenge carries considerable weight with adjudicators; a report the tenant says they never saw carries little.

The check-out report

The check-out repeats the exercise on the day the tenancy ends, against the same entries and in the same format, so that the two can be read side by side. Record the meter readings, count the keys back in, and note the date and who attended. Take comparison photographs from the same positions as the check-in. If the tenant has left items behind, list them. If anything has been repaired or replaced during the tenancy, say so, because the check-in entry for that item is no longer the baseline.

Do the check-out before any cleaning or work starts. Evidence of condition gathered after the contractors have been in is evidence of nothing.

Fair wear and tear

A tenant is not liable for deterioration that results from reasonable use of the premises and the ordinary operation of natural forces, which is the test in Haskell v Marlow [1928], approved by the House of Lords in Regis Property Co v Dudley [1959], and which the schemes apply. Light scuffing on walls after two years, worn carpet in a hallway, a sun-faded curtain: wear and tear. A burn on the worktop, a door off its hinges, a carpet stained with red wine: damage. The length of the tenancy, the number of occupiers and the quality and age of the item at the start all feed into the line, and the check-in report is where the age and quality are recorded.

Even for damage, the landlord does not get new for old. Adjudicators apportion the cost of replacement by reference to the item's expected lifespan and its age, so a five-year-old carpet with a ten-year life that is ruined in year five attracts roughly half of the replacement cost, not all of it. A landlord who cannot show how old the carpet was at check-in will struggle to show that any of it is recoverable.

Cleaning, the most common deduction

Cleaning claims succeed or fail on the comparison of cleanliness at the two ends. The tenant's obligation is to return the property to the standard of cleanliness recorded at check-in, allowing for wear and tear, not to a higher standard. A clause requiring the tenant to pay for professional cleaning at the end of the tenancy is a prohibited term under the Tenant Fees Act 2019 and cannot be enforced; a clause requiring the property to be returned as clean as it was let is fine. Grade cleanliness room by room at check-in with photographs of the oven, the extractor, the bathroom grout and the insides of cupboards, because those are where claims are made.

What an adjudicator wants to see

For a deduction to succeedEvidence that worksEvidence that fails
Condition at the startSigned check-in with specific entries and dated photosUnsigned list, photos with no descriptions, nothing at all
Condition at the endCheck-out in the same format, done before any work, with comparison photosPhotos taken after cleaners or decorators have been in
Breach by the tenantA difference between the two that is beyond wear and tearDeterioration consistent with the length of the tenancy
Amount of the lossInvoices or two quotations, apportioned for age and lifespanRound-figure estimates, new-for-old claims
AgreementTenant signed, or was sent the report and given a window to objectTenant first saw the inventory in the dispute

Periodic tenancies make this more important, not less

Under the Renters' Rights Act 2025 a new assured tenancy in England has no fixed end point, so the check-in you prepare today may be compared with a check-out five or eight years from now. That lengthens the wear-and-tear allowance and raises the value of mid-term inspection records: a dated note and photographs every six or twelve months, shared with the tenant, keep the baseline current and show when a problem started. The written statement of terms the landlord must give under section 16D of the Housing Act 1988 includes information about the deposit and about repairs; it is not a substitute for an inventory. For what else a 2026 tenancy agreement has to cover, see our guide to the Renters' Rights Act and your tenancy agreement.

Lodgers, too

None of the deposit scheme rules apply to a lodger living with a resident landlord, but the evidential logic is identical: if the lodger disputes a deduction and sues in the small claims court, the judge asks the same questions an adjudicator would. A room inventory signed on day one, with photographs, is what wins. Our guide to ending a lodger agreement covers the deposit mechanics for resident landlords.

A practical routine

  • Prepare the inventory after the property has been cleaned and before the tenant moves in, not from memory a week later.
  • Walk the property with the tenant at check-in, agree the entries on the spot and sign.
  • Record meter readings, keys and alarm tests on the same document.
  • Send a copy within a day and note the seven-day comment window in the covering email.
  • Inspect periodically with notice, and record what you find.
  • At check-out, same format, same photo positions, before any work.
  • Agree deductions with the tenant in writing where you can; the schemes require the undisputed balance to be returned within 10 days of agreement, and the dispute service only deals with what is actually contested.

Document you will need

Our Property Inventory & Schedule of Condition is structured the way adjudicators expect to read evidence: one row per element in every room, check-in and check-out columns side by side, a condition and cleanliness grading key of the kind adjudicators expect, meter readings, keys, alarm tests, a photo log, a check-in declaration with the seven-day tenant comment window and a check-out declaration, with guidance notes on how fair wear and tear is assessed. It works with any tenancy or lodger agreement anywhere in the UK and is included in the Landlord Pack 2026 alongside the tenancy agreement, written statement of terms and guarantor deed. Lawyer drafted, editable Word and PDF, instant download. It is a general precedent; for a high-value furnished property, an independent inventory clerk is money well spent.